Stereotyping is something humans naturally do to help conceptualize and classify the complexities of the world. However, these assumptions can be irritating or even damaging to the groups they are about.
Our team at Mindfully American researched assumptions Americans have about certain U.S. cities and analyzed why they are stereotypes gone wrong, aiming to shed a more correct light on the cities included.
Here are some of the most unfair reputations certain U.S. cities and areas have:
1. Detroit Is Scary
While certain areas of Detroit may be “rough around the edges,” the reputation for crime often precedes the city.
Recent news shows significant progress: In 2023, Detroit reported the lowest number of homicides in 57 years, and the city also saw a double-digit drop in shootings and carjackings. Despite these strides, the stereotype of Detroit being dangerous is likely to persist for years to come.
2. Las Vegas Equals the Strip
According to Las Vegas residents, there is much more to the city than just the Strip. Many tourists unfortunately head straight to the Strip without exploring other options.
Outside the Strip, you can find excellent restaurant options and fascinating museums like the Mob Museum and the Neon Museum. Las Vegas is also surrounded by great natural areas like Red Rock Canyon for getting outdoors.
3. Cleveland Is Boring
Contrary to the stereotype, Cleveland is not a boring city. Travel writer Eric Weiner noted that so-called “boring” cities like Cleveland can feel “fresher,” are less crowded, and offer travelers a better sense of local culture. The source also highlights that Cleveland is home to exceptional restaurants.
4. Salt Lake City Is for Mormons
While it’s true that a significant portion of Salt Lake City’s population is Mormon (49% based on recent data), the assumption that it’s a “no-fun-allowed” or backward place from the 19th century is inaccurate.
Tourists visiting Salt Lake City have plenty of fun options, including ghost tours and nightclubs, some of which the Church of Latter-day Saints would not approve of.
5. Los Angeles Only Has Hollywood
Los Angeles offers far more than just Hollywood or the Santa Monica Pier. Theme park enthusiasts can choose from six theme parks, including Knott’s Berry Farm.
Other recommended activities include a day trip to Catalina Island by ferry and exploring hiking trails in Griffith Park.
6. Crime Is Out of Control in Chicago
The reputation of Chicago being a dangerous city is a broad statement that overlooks the several relatively safe areas within the city. Recent crime data does not support the idea that crime is “out of control”.
In 2023, Chicago experienced a significant drop in the number of murders, shootings, and shooting victims across all three categories.
7. Huntsville Has Nothing
This stereotype lingers despite Huntsville being the largest city in its state. NASA, which has its Marshall Space Flight Center located there, would certainly disagree with the notion that Huntsville offers little.
8. New Jersey Shore Is Atlantic City
While not a city, the New Jersey Shore (or “the Shore” to locals) is often stereotyped due to the TV show Jersey Shore.
This has led some to believe the entire Shore resembles the casino hub of Atlantic City. However, the Jersey Shore is mostly a peaceful place often enjoyed by families.
9. Sacramento Is a Cowtown
Historically, the Sacramento Valley region was indeed known for its large cow population; in 1860, the majority of California’s 104,000 cows were in the Sacramento and San Francisco Bay areas.
However, times have significantly changed. Sacramento’s population has grown immensely, and it is now home to universities, shopping malls, and a vibrant restaurant scene.
10. DC Is All Politics
Although much of Washington, D.C., does revolve around politics, there are many non-political activities available.
Beyond visiting landmarks like the White House and Washington Monument, you can enjoy rowboating at Fletcher’s Cove or visit the Eastern Market for fresh seafood and local artwork (even if it is located on Capitol Hill).
11. Philadelphia Is Expensive
While costs have generally increased everywhere, the stereotype that Philadelphia is expensive is considered unfair and even laughable to residents of San Diego, which is statistically in the most expensive state.
However, Philadelphia’s reputation for being expensive might be rooted in its utility and grocery costs, which RentCafe indicates are 10% and 3% higher than the national average, respectively.
12. Cincinnati Is a Rust Belt City (in a negative sense)
Technically, Cincinnati is located in the Rust Belt. However, it does not fit the stereotype of Rust Belt cities being poverty-stricken areas that haven’t recovered from deindustrialization.
Data shows a steady increase in per capita income, a thriving professional sports culture, and a growing selection of restaurants.
13. Flagstaff Is Warm
Flagstaff can get hot during summer days, but many tourists are surprised to find it also gets freezing cold.
Snow and sleet are common during the winter, so visitors planning to see the Grand Canyon from here should pack warm clothing.
14. Mobile Has a Southern Vibe (like all others)
Mobile, Alabama, is often grouped culturally with other southern cities, but this isn’t entirely fair. Mobile is distinct due to its history of being home to people from a mix of origins, starting with the French settlers.
Alicia Richards