Boston is renowned not just for its history and sports, but also for its top-notch bagel shops. From classic to inventive flavors, these seven bagel havens cater to every palate.
Bagelsaurus in Cambridge offers artisanal bagels with unique combinations like pretzel bagels. Exodus Bagels in Jamaica Plain adds creative toppings and fillings to elevate traditional bagels.
Black Sheep Bagel Cafe in Cambridge stands out for its large, chewy bagels and unique cream cheese flavors. Each of these shops brings something special, making Boston a must-visit for bagel enthusiasts.
Rounding out the list, Kupel’s Bakery in Brookline is a cherished spot known for its traditional Jewish-style bagels. Rosenfeld’s Bagels in Newton offers a cozy atmosphere and consistently delicious, hand-rolled bagels.
Mamaleh’s in Kendall Square serves up bagels alongside other deli favorites, making it perfect for a brunch outing.
Lastly, Finagle a Bagel has multiple locations around the city, ensuring that everyone can grab a freshly baked treat anytime.
Top 7 Best Bagel Shops in Boston
Boston is home to a vibrant food scene, and bagels are no exception.
From classic New York-style bagels to creative gourmet twists, here are the top 7 bagel shops in Boston that stand out for their flavor, variety, and quality:
1. Bagelsaurus
Bagelsaurus, located at 1796 Massachusetts Ave in Cambridge, is a must-visit for any bagel enthusiast. Known for its unique handmade bagels, Bagelsaurus offers a variety of options, including classic buttered bagels and creative sandwiches.
This popular spot, with a rating of 4.6 out of 5 from 1,464 reviews, serves high-quality bagels priced between $10 and $20 per person.
Open for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, Bagelsaurus should be on top of your list. The shop reportedly gets busy, so arriving early or ordering ahead is recommended.
Offering everything from a standard schmear to elaborate creations, Bagelsaurus continues to impress both locals and visitors. Check out their menu on toasttab.com or visit their website, bagelsaurus.com, for more details.
2. Goldilox Bagels
Goldilox Bagels, located at 186 Winthrop St, Medford, MA, boasts an impressive rating of 4.8 out of 5 from 375 reviews.
Known for its delicious bagels priced between $1 and $10, this neighborhood gem offers a delightful menu that includes classic and creative bagel options. Reported by 20 people, the modest price range makes it accessible to a wide audience.
This shop opens its doors at 8 AM and is ideal for both takeout and dine-in experiences. Convenient online ordering at order.goldiloxbagels.com simplifies the process of choosing your favorites. If you’re in the area, don’t forget to check it out and enjoy a freshly made bagel.
3. Wicked Bagel
Wicked Bagel in Lexington, MA, is a top contender for Boston’s best bagel shops. With a solid rating of 4.3 out of 5 from 481 reviews, this bagel haven offers a variety of delicious options priced between $1 and $10 per person.
Located at 171 Massachusetts Ave, Wicked Bagel opens its doors at 7 AM, making it perfect for an early morning breakfast run.
Patrons can choose to dine in, take out, or opt for delivery. The bagel shop’s menu, which can be accessed through order.labrador.ai, features a range of classic bagels and innovative flavors that cater to both traditionalists and those seeking something new.
With affordable prices and rave reviews, Wicked Bagel stands out as a must-visit for bagel lovers.
4. House of Bagels
House of Bagels, located at 162 Main St, Reading, MA, stands out with its impressive 4.7 rating from 250 reviews.
With prices ranging from $1 to $10 per person, it’s an affordable spot for a delicious bite. The bagel shop opens early at 6 AM, making it a convenient option for breakfast or a morning snack.
Patrons can enjoy dine-in, takeout, or delivery services. The extensive menu, available online, features a variety of classic and unique bagel options.
Whether you’re a fan of traditional flavors or seeking something innovative, House of Bagels has something to satisfy every craving. For more details, you can contact them at (781) 872-1269 or visit their website.
5. Rosenfeld Bagel Co
Rosenfeld Bagel Co, located at 1280 Centre St, Newton, MA, is a must-visit spot for bagel enthusiasts. This highly-rated shop, with an impressive 4.6 out of 5 from 398 reviews, offers bagels priced between $1 and $10.
The shop is known for its wide array of cream cheese flavors, challah bread, and special holiday offerings. Rosenfeld Bagel Co provides curbside pickup, no-contact delivery, and dine-in options, making it convenient for all preferences.
They open early at 7 AM, perfect for breakfast or a morning snack. To place an order, visit their website, RosenfeldsBagels.com, or call (617) 527-8080.
6. Finagle A Bagel
Finagle A Bagel, located at 535 Boylston St, Boston, is a cozy destination for bagel lovers. With a solid rating of 4.1 from 486 reviews, this shop provides a variety of options priced between $10 and $20 per person.
Their menu features a range of sandwiches, artisan breads, baked goods, soups, and other café fare.
Patrons can enjoy dine-in, takeout, or no-contact delivery, catering to different preferences and schedules. The shop opens at 7 AM, perfect for early risers seeking a delicious breakfast.
Popular among locals, Finagle A Bagel’s reputation for quality and comfort makes it a staple in the Boston bagel scene.
7. Bruegger’s Bagels
Bruegger’s Bagels, a renowned bagel shop, is located at 2050 Commonwealth Ave, Auburndale, MA. This New York-style bagel shop boasts a solid rating of 4.0 from 374 reviews, making it a favorite destination. With prices ranging from $1 to $10 per person, it’s an affordable choice for breakfast or lunch.
Opening early at 6 AM, Bruegger’s Bagels provides a perfect spot for early risers. They offer dine-in, takeout, and no-contact delivery options, catering to various customer preferences.
Their extensive menu includes breakfast and lunch sandwiches, ensuring a variety of tasty choices.
Patrons appreciate its small-batch, freshly baked bagels, which contribute to its popularity. For more details or to place an order, visit brueggers.com or call (617) 964-9508.
What to Look for When Choosing Bagel Shops in Boston
When choosing the best bagel shop in Boston, there are several key factors to consider to ensure you get a top-notch bagel experience.
Here’s what to look for:
Bagel Texture and Quality
When looking for a great bagel shop in Boston, one of the first things to pay attention to is the texture and quality of the bagels themselves.
Traditional bagels are boiled before baking, which gives them that perfect combination of a chewy interior and a crisp, golden crust.
This classic technique is often a marker of quality. Freshness is equally important; bagels should be baked daily to ensure they are soft and flavorful.
Stale bagels, which may have been sitting out for hours, can significantly diminish your experience, so opt for shops where freshness is a priority.
Variety of Bagels and Flavors
A great bagel shop offers a balance of both classic and creative bagel flavors.
Traditional varieties such as plain, sesame, poppy seed, and everything bagels are a must, but it’s exciting to see shops that experiment with unique flavors, such as asiago, jalapeño cheddar, or seasonal options.
For those with specific dietary needs, it’s helpful to find places that offer gluten-free or vegan alternatives, as this expands accessibility and caters to a wider range of preferences.
High-Quality Spreads and Toppings
In addition to the bagels themselves, the quality of spreads and toppings plays a crucial role. Many top bagel shops offer house-made cream cheese in a variety of flavors, such as plain, scallion, veggie, or more adventurous combinations like honey rosemary or jalapeño.
The ability to choose from a range of spreads can elevate your bagel experience. Shops that go beyond basic toppings and offer full bagel sandwiches with ingredients like lox, avocado, bacon, or egg will provide you with more options to customize your meal.
Bagel Sandwiches
One feature that sets some Boston bagel shops apart is the quality of their bagel sandwiches. Many places offer creative sandwiches that go beyond the typical bagel-and-cream-cheese combo.
Options might include smoked salmon and cream cheese, bacon-egg-and-cheese, or turkey and avocado sandwiches.
These hearty options can be great for breakfast or lunch, making the bagel shop a versatile stop for different times of the day.
Additionally, finding a shop that allows for customization lets you create the perfect sandwich tailored to your tastes.
Local Reputation and Reviews
When choosing a bagel shop, it’s important to consider its local reputation. Customer reviews often provide valuable insights into the consistency and quality of the bagels.
The best bagel shops are known for maintaining high standards over time, and this reliability is key to finding a place you can return to regularly.
Reviews on platforms like Yelp or Google are helpful, as they reflect the experiences of other patrons, and word-of-mouth recommendations from Boston locals can guide you toward hidden gems that might not be widely known.
Atmosphere and Service
The overall atmosphere and service of a bagel shop can also influence your experience. Some shops offer a cozy, welcoming environment, ideal for sitting down with a bagel and coffee.
Others might focus more on quick, efficient service for those who are grabbing a bite on the go. Depending on your personal preference, you might favor one type of shop over another.
Customer service is another factor to consider; friendly and attentive staff can make your visit more pleasant, especially if you’re visiting during busy morning hours.
Location and Accessibility
In a bustling city like Boston, location is key. Whether you’re heading to work, school, or exploring the city, it’s helpful to find a bagel shop that is conveniently located.
Many popular shops are near T stops or in easily accessible neighborhoods. Additionally, consider whether the shop offers takeout or delivery options, especially if you’re in a rush or prefer to enjoy your bagel from home.
Accessibility, both in terms of location and service options, can save you time and make your visit more convenient.
Pricing and Value
Pricing is an important factor when choosing a bagel shop. While some places may charge a premium for their gourmet offerings, it’s important to find a balance between cost and quality.
A well-made bagel is worth a little extra, but it’s good to be mindful of shops that might overcharge for standard items.
Consider the portion sizes as well; some shops are known for offering generously sized bagels and sandwiches, which provide better value for your money. It’s always a good idea to weigh the price against the overall experience and quality.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where is Bagelsaurus located, and what is it known for?
Bagelsaurus is located in Cambridge, MA. It is known for its unique handmade bagels and creative sandwiches.
What is the rating and price range of Goldilox Bagels?
Goldilox Bagels has a rating of 4.8 out of 5 from 375 reviews. The price range is between $1 and $10.
What makes Wicked Bagel a top contender for Boston’s best bagel shops?
Wicked Bagel, located in Lexington, MA, offers a variety of delicious bagel options and has a rating of 4.3 out of 5 from 481 reviews. It’s known for its diverse menu.
Why is House of Bagels popular?
House of Bagels in Reading, MA, is popular due to its impressive rating of 4.7 out of 5 from 250 reviews and its wide array of classic and unique bagel options.
What special offerings does Rosenfeld Bagel Co provide?
Rosenfeld Bagel Co, located in Newton, MA, offers various cream cheese flavors, challah bread, and special holiday offerings, alongside its highly-rated bagels.
What can patrons expect at Finagle A Bagel?
Located in Boston, MA, Finagle A Bagel offers sandwiches, artisan breads, baked goods, soups, and other café fare with a rating of 4.1 from 486 reviews.
Conclusion
With a diverse mix of traditional and innovative flavors, Boston’s bagel shops offer something for everyone.
From the handmade delights at Bagelsaurus to the cozy, neighborhood charm of Goldilox Bagels, there’s a bagel haven for every taste.
Wicked Bagel, House of Bagels, and Rosenfeld Bagel Co provide countless options, whether for a quick breakfast or a leisurely brunch.
Finagle A Bagel’s sandwiches and artisan breads, along with Bruegger’s Bagels’ New York-style offerings, round out the city’s dynamic bagel scene.
Whether you’re a local or just visiting, Boston’s best bagel shops are sure to impress. Plan your visit to these top communities, and savor every bite, from classic plain with a schmear to bold, inventive combinations. Boston’s bagel scene is a must-experience culinary adventure.
Natalie Kurtzman