Welcome to the definitive guide exploring the most highly-regarded pizza selections from Pizza Hut, based on a curated list of personal favorites and noted highlights found within the sources.
This list provides valuable insights into the top contenders, offering an array of flavors from foundational classics to bold, spicy specialty options.
Whether you are a newcomer to Pizza Hut’s menu or a seasoned fan looking for new appreciation, this listing format breaks down the elements that make these pizzas stand out, drawing directly from subjective experiences and recent menu additions detailed in the sources.
Please note that this ranking reflects individual assessments and sometimes mentions items whose availability the original commentator was unsure of. Prepare to explore the list of items considered the best pizzas from Pizza Hut.
1. Cheese Pan Pizza
This classic item is celebrated as a foundational choice and is highly regarded as the source author’s favorite kind of pizza.
The commentary suggests that this particular option might be considered the “father of cheese pizza,” marking it as a critical and great starting point for any pizza journey.
The appeal lies in the combination of delicious melty cheese, a yummy crust, and a nice sauce, creating a satisfying and comforting experience.
Furthermore, the reviewer notes that the regular version of this pizza is considered perfectly fine and delicious as is, suggesting that no special modifications are necessary to enjoy its quality.
This highlights the inherent excellence of the traditional pan pizza format, providing valuable insight into why simple, classic recipes often remain the most beloved options for both beginners and long-time aficionados. The emphasis here is on quality ingredients delivering maximum flavor.
2. Pepperoni Pan Pizza
The Pepperoni Pan Pizza makes this exclusive list, recognizing its popularity among broader audiences, even though the original source author is a vegetarian.
While the source author stated they were not exactly sure if this item is currently sold by Pizza Hut, it is included because of the understanding that many people enjoy pepperoni.
This inclusion ensures that popular meat toppings are represented among the top-rated items, catering to a wide range of preferences.
For those who prioritize traditional and hearty toppings, pepperoni is often seen as the quintessential pizza experience, pairing perfectly with the delicious crust and nice sauce praised in other pan pizza varieties.
The recognition of this pizza, despite the commentator’s personal dietary restrictions, underscores its perceived universal appeal and status as a highly desirable topping option among pizza lovers.
This highlights how essential pepperoni is to the top pizza offerings, even when judged by external measures.
3. Garlic Special Pizza
The Garlic Special Pizza is highlighted as a new and exciting contender, having “just came out a few weeks ago in April” according to the sources.
The introduction of this specific menu item signals Pizza Hut’s commitment to offering seasonal or limited-time specialty flavors.
The simple assessment of this new pizza is that “it was good,” which, coming from a highly selective list, suggests a worthwhile and pleasant flavor profile.
The inclusion of garlic as the primary flavor suggests a rich and aromatic taste experience that would appeal to advanced users looking for sophisticated or savory profiles beyond the usual standards.
For beginners, trying a recently introduced item like the Garlic Special offers a chance to sample innovative recipes.
The very recent release date in April emphasizes its timely appearance on the menu, making it a fresh consideration for anyone seeking high-quality, new pizza options.
4. Green Pepper Pan Pizza
The Green Pepper Pan Pizza is noted with genuine enthusiasm, with the commentator declaring it “Yummy!” and explicitly stating, “I like green peppers on pizza, especially this one!”.
This pizza capitalizes on the fresh, slightly bitter, and crisp taste that green peppers bring to the baked pizza format.
The specific endorsement of this particular version indicates that the quality of the peppers and how they integrate with the crust and sauce—potentially similar to the “yummy crust and nice sauce” of the Cheese Pan Pizza—creates a superior vegetable-topped experience.
For both beginners exploring vegetable toppings and advanced users seeking robust flavor, the Green Pepper Pan Pizza provides a flavorful, classic alternative to meat-heavy options.
The strong subjective preference for this item ensures its spot among the best, underlining the fact that simple, well-executed vegetable pizzas can be highly satisfying.
5. Crazy Crust Pizza
The Crazy Crust Pizza is listed as another strong option, though the source expresses uncertainty about whether it is still being sold.
Despite the potential uncertainty regarding its current availability, the memory and assessment of the pizza remain positive: “it was pretty good”.
This suggests that during its time on the menu, the unique crust formulation or preparation provided a memorable and enjoyable eating experience.
For advanced users, items with specialty crusts, like the Crazy Crust, often represent innovation and are highly sought after for textural differentiation.
While the details of what made the crust “crazy” are not provided, its inclusion in the top list indicates that the novelty or enhanced texture significantly contributed to its high standing.
The positive retrospective review solidifies its status as one of the best pizzas offered by the chain.
6. Olive Pan Pizza
The Olive Pan Pizza offers a distinct, savory flavor profile, appealing to those who appreciate the salty, earthy taste of olives.
While the reviewer confirms, “I like this kind of pizza,” they also clarify that it is “Not my favorite, but it’s good!”. This balanced endorsement places it firmly in the category of solid, reliable, and high-quality pizza options.
Olives—likely black olives in this context, although the source doesn’t specify—provide an intensity that complements the cheese and sauce of the pan base.
This option is excellent for beginners who want a vegetarian option with a bolder taste than plain cheese, and for advanced users who appreciate the classic pairing of olives and pizza.
Its reliable “good” rating ensures its inclusion among the top contenders for best Pizza Hut offerings.
7. Ultimate Supreme
The Ultimate Supreme is listed as a top-tier choice, representing the pinnacle of topping combinations.
While the source material lists this item without detailed commentary, the name itself suggests a maximalist approach to ingredients, typically featuring a variety of meats, vegetables, and possibly different cheeses.
For consumers, “Supreme” offerings usually denote the most complete and comprehensive pizza experience available.
This makes it an ideal choice for beginners who want to sample a wide array of classic pizza flavors in a single slice, and for advanced users who expect a robust, flavor-packed meal.
The presence of “Ultimate Supreme” on this highly subjective list implies that, by popular opinion or inherent quality, this combination surpasses standard supreme varieties, securing its place among the best.
8. Jalapeno Pizza
For customers who seek significant heat and a powerful spice kick, the Jalapeno Pizza is highly recommended.
The simple and direct description is that it is “Really hot which means it’s good!”. This unambiguous statement confirms the pizza’s successful delivery of intense heat, appealing directly to those who favor spicy cuisine.
The inclusion of fresh or pickled jalapeno peppers provides a sharp, fiery contrast to the rich cheese and savory sauce of the pan crust.
This item is perfect for advanced users who actively seek out the hottest options on the menu. Beginners should approach the Jalapeno Pizza with caution due to the strong heat level, which is a definitive characteristic of the dish. The fact that its heat is equated with quality makes it a standout choice on this list.
9. Banana Peppers Pizza
The Banana Peppers Pizza is distinguished by an extraordinarily high level of enthusiasm from the source author, who emphatically states, “I LOVE Banana peppers! Especially on pizza!”.
This intense personal preference guarantees its spot in the top ranking. Banana peppers typically offer a milder, tangy sweetness compared to the fiery kick of jalapenos.
They provide a bright, slightly pickled counterpoint to the richness of the pizza base, enhancing the overall flavor profile with a delightful acidity.
This pizza is excellent for those who enjoy pickled flavors and tanginess but want to avoid excessive spice, making it a balanced and flavorful choice.
The passionate endorsement highlights how effective this specific, unique topping is in creating a memorable and beloved pizza experience.
10. Pineapple Pizza
The Pineapple Pizza rounds out the top ten, included specifically because the commentator recognizes its widespread appeal despite their own personal reservations.
The source notes, “I don’t really [like] pineapple on my pizzas, but I know you do!”. This decision to include a personally disliked item based on its external popularity is a testament to the fact that pineapple pizza—known for its combination of sweet fruit and savory ham or bacon—is a major menu fixture.
This polarizing topping offers a sweet and acidic flavor contrast that many people find irresistible.
The inclusion serves as a nod to the widespread debate and popularity of fruit toppings, ensuring that all popular flavor camps are represented in this curated list of the best pizzas.
Declan Kelly