History and Traditions

Journeying Beyond: Delving into the Stories of West Tisbury’s 18 Historic Landmarks

West Tisbury, Massachusetts, located on the island of Martha’s Vineyard, is steeped in rich history and features a range of historical landmarks and sites.

This small town offers picturesque views of coastal New England and allows visitors to step back in time with its well-preserved 19th-century architecture and meaningful archaeological sites.

From the iconic Mill Pond to the rustic Grange Hall and Alley’s General Store, the oldest operating business in its original location on the island, these historical landmarks tell the story of West Tisbury’s scenic and fascinating past.

1. Rev. Thomas Mayhew, Jr. Place on The WaySide


Rev. Thomas Mayhew, Jr.’s Place on the WaySide is one of the historical places in Tisbury, MA, USA. This place holds significant historical importance, but unfortunately, no specific description is available for it.

Despite the lack of details about the place, its significance cannot be undermined. Tisbury, located in Massachusetts, is rich in history and culture.

It is home to various historical landmarks that attract tourists and history enthusiasts alike. One such place is the Rev.

Thomas Mayhew, Jr. Place on The Wayside. Although devoid of a description, this historical site holds a story waiting to be explored. The absence of information about the place allows visitors to embark on a journey of discovery.

Rating: 8

Address: 794 Edgartown – West Tisbury Rd, Edgartown, MA 02539, United States

2. Heath Hen Monument


The Heath Hen Monument in Tisbury, MA, USA, is a significant historical place. The monument commemorates the extinct Heath Hen species that once inhabited Martha’s Vineyard, including the Tisbury area.

The Heath Hen was a prairie chicken native to the eastern United States. Unfortunately, the Heath Hen became extinct in 1932 due to habitat loss and overhunting.

The monument serves as a reminder of this tragic loss and the importance of preserving endangered species. Located in a picturesque spot in Tisbury, the monument stands tall and proud, symbolizing the resilience and beauty of the Heath Hen.

It is a solemn reminder of the impact of human activities on the natural world. Visiting the Heath Hen.

Rating: 10

Address: 99P4+GJ, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568, United States

3. Sepiessa Point Reservation


Located in West Tisbury, Sepiessa Point Reservation is a hidden gem that offers a variety of activities for visitors to enjoy.

This beautiful natural area provides a tranquil environment, perfect for those seeking a peaceful escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. One of the main attractions at Sepiessa Point Reservation is the hiking trails.

The reservation features several well-maintained trails that wind through the picturesque landscape, offering stunning views of the surrounding nature.

Whether you are an experienced hiker or just looking for a stroll, there is a trail suitable for everyone.

As you explore the trails, you can spot local wildlife and observe the diverse flora and fauna that call this place home for those who enjoy it.

Rating: 9.6

Address: Clam Point Rd, West Tisbury, MA 02575, United States

Website: mvlandbank.com

4. Polly Hill Arboretum


Tisbury, a charming town in Massachusetts, is home to several historical places worth exploring.

One such place is the Polly Hill Arboretum, a stunning botanical landmark that spans 60 acres of woodlands, showcasing rare trees and seasonal flowers. The Polly Hill Arboretum is a true gem for nature enthusiasts and history buffs.

Its vast expanse of woodlands provides visitors with a serene and peaceful environment, perfect for a stroll or a picnic amidst nature’s beauty.


The arboretum’s well-maintained trails meander through the property, allowing visitors to explore and discover the various plant species that call this place home. One of the highlights of the Polly Hill Arboretum is its collection of rare trees.

Rating: 9.6

Phone: +1 508-693-9426

Address: 809 State Rd, West Tisbury, MA 02575, United States

Website: pollyhillarboretum.org

5. Old Mill


The Old Mill in Egremont, MA, USA, is a historic landmark worth visiting. This weathered grist mill, built around 1797, has been transformed into a cozy eatery.

The mill’s rustic charm adds to the unique dining experience it offers. Inside the Old Mill, you will find a restaurant specializing in posh modern fare.

The menu is carefully crafted, offering a range of delicious dishes made with fresh and locally sourced ingredients.

Each plate, from appetizers to desserts, is thoughtfully prepared to satisfy your taste buds. In addition to the main dining area, the Old Mill also boasts a bar menu. Here, you can enjoy a variety of handcrafted cocktails, fine wines, and local beers.

Address: Vineyard Haven, MA 02568, United States

6. Brick Yard


In the quaint town of Chilmark, MA, USA, visitors can find a unique and intriguing museum, the Brick Yard. This museum stands out among the others in the area due to its diverse collection of artifacts and immersive exhibits.

Located in the heart of Chilmark, the Brick Yard Museum offers an enriching experience for locals and tourists alike.

Despite its relatively humble appearance from the outside, stepping inside reveals a treasure trove of historical and cultural significance.

Upon entering the museum, visitors are greeted by a knowledgeable and friendly staff eager to share their passion for the exhibits.

The museum’s interior is thoughtfully designed, with each section dedicated to a specific period or theme—one of the most captivating aspects.

Rating: 9.6

Address: Gosnold’s Way, Chilmark, MA 02535, United States

Website: thetrustees.org

7. First Congregational Church of West Tisbury


The First Congregational Church of West Tisbury is a historic landmark in West Tisbury, Massachusetts.

This church is essential in the town’s history and is a must-visit for anyone interested in the region’s past. Constructed in the 19th century, the church stands as a testament to the architectural style of that era.

The white-washed exterior and tall, commanding steeple are typical New England church designs. The interior, though simple, is imbued with a sense of tranquility and reverence. The church has served the community of West Tisbury for generations.

As the town grew and changed, the First Congregational Church remained a constant, unchanging symbol of faith and community spirit.

Rating: 9.6

Phone: +1 508-693-2842

Address: 1051 State Rd, West Tisbury, MA 02575, United States

Website: wtcongregationalchurch.org

8. Martha’s Vineyard Museum


The Martha’s Vineyard Museum in Chilmark, MA, USA, is a must-visit for history and culture enthusiasts.

This museum is home to several historic buildings that house captivating exhibits, showcasing the rich and diverse history of the island from pre-colonial times to the modern era.

One of the main highlights of the Martha’s Vineyard Museum is its collection of historic buildings.

These buildings have been carefully preserved and restored to their original grandeur, offering visitors a glimpse into the island’s past.

Walking through these structures is like stepping back in time, immersing yourself in the island’s history. Inside these buildings, you will find a wide range of exhibits that explore various aspects of Martha’s Vineyard’s history and culture.

Rating: 9.2

Phone: +1 508-627-4441

Address: 151 Lagoon Pond Rd, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568, United States

Website: mvmuseum.org

9. Old Millpond


Old Millpond in West Tisbury, MA, USA, is an intriguing historical site for locals and visitors alike.

This site brings a unique blend of natural beauty and rich history, making it an ideal destination for history enthusiasts and nature lovers. The heart of West Tisbury, Old Millpond is considered an iconic symbol of the town’s history.

Its name alone reflects its age-old function as a pond for a mill.


This hints at the area’s industrial past, where mills played a significant role in the local economy. While the details of its history are somewhat lost in time, the Old Millpond continues to tell a silent, untold story of its past.

Its tranquil waters and the surrounding lush greenery serve as a beautiful.

Rating: 9.4

Address: West Tisbury, MA 02568, USA

10. West Tisbury Village Cemetery


The West Tisbury Village Cemetery is located in the heart of West Tisbury, Massachusetts. This cemetery is not just a final resting place but also a significant historical site in this quaint town.

The cemetery is a significant landmark that has been integral to the town’s history. West Tisbury Village Cemetery offers a glimpse into the past, hosting gravestones that date back to the town’s early days.

These gravestones tell a unique story about the people who once lived in this community, making it a treasure trove for history enthusiasts.

The cemetery is a quiet spot where visitors can reflect on the lives of past generations. The cemetery is beautifully maintained, preserving the historical integrity of the place—the old gravestones.

Rating: 9

Phone: +1 508-696-4220

Address: 299 State Rd, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568, United States

Website: tisburyma.gov

11. The Overton House


“The Overton House” in Tisbury, MA, USA, holds significant historical importance. This exquisite structure stands as a symbol of the town’s rich heritage.

Built in the 18th century, it has witnessed the passage of time and played a crucial role in shaping the community’s identity.

Amidst picturesque landscapes, “The Overton House” proudly showcases its magnificent colonial architecture.

Its grand facade, characterized by a blend of Georgian and Federal styles, evokes a sense of awe and admiration.

The meticulously crafted details, such as the ornate cornices and symmetrical design, speak volumes about the skilled craftsmanship of the era. As one enters this historic house, reverence fills the air. The interior is adorned with period.

Rating: 9.4

Address: Narragansett Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557, United States

12. Vincent House Museum


Located in Chilmark, MA, USA, the Vincent House Museum is a prominent cultural destination that offers visitors a unique glimpse into the history and heritage of the area.

Amidst the picturesque surroundings of Chilmark, this museum stands as a testament to the community’s rich past.

Visitors are immediately transported back in time by stepping inside the Vincent House Museum.


The museum boasts an impressive collection of artifacts and exhibits that tell the story of Chilmark’s evolution.

From its humble beginnings as a small farming community to its present-day status as a beloved tourist destination, the museum offers a comprehensive overview of the area’s past.

The Vincent House Museum serves as a hub of knowledge with a focus on preserving the local heritage.

Rating: 9.6

Phone: +1 508-627-8017

Address: 99 Main St, Edgartown, MA 02539, United States

Website: vineyardtrust.org

13. Old House Pond


Old House Pond, located in West Tisbury, MA, is a historical place with charm and significance. The name itself suggests an old-world charm; true to that, this location holds a rich history dating back several centuries.

The pond is renowned for its captivating beauty and serene environment. Its sparkling waters reflect the lush, green surroundings, creating a picture-perfect scene that has inspired numerous artists and photographers.

Old House Pond is not just a natural attraction; it has historical value. It’s been a vital resource for the local community for centuries, providing water for farming and other uses.

This makes it an integral part of West Tisbury’s history and heritage. The pond is surrounded by old.

Rating: 10

Address: West Tisbury, MA 02568, USA

14. Toad Rock


Toad Rock is a captivating historical landmark in Tisbury, Massachusetts, USA.

Despite its name, the place does not resemble an actual toad; instead, it boasts a rich and fascinating history that has intrigued locals and tourists for generations.

Situated amidst the picturesque landscape of Tisbury, Toad Rock stands as a testament to the town’s heritage.


Its origins date back to the early colonial period when European settlers established settlements in the area.

The rock is an immense granite formation that has witnessed centuries of history unfold before its stoic presence. The absence of a description for Toad Rock, but that should not undermine its significance.

The lack of information only adds to this history’s allure and mystique.

Rating: 6.4

Address: 4 Towhee Ln, Aquinnah, MA 02535, United States

15. Flower of the Winds


“Flower of the Winds” is a historical place in Tisbury, MA, USA. Despite its intriguing name, the description of this place.

There is limited information available about its history, significance, or any notable features it holds. However, the lack of details regarding the “Flower of the Winds” does not diminish the potential allure it may possess.

Sometimes, the mystery surrounding a place can be just as captivating as its known history.

It leaves room for imagination and sparks curiosity in those who come across its name.

Perhaps, in the past, the “Flower of the Winds” held a crucial role in Tisbury’s development or served as a gathering place for the community. It could have been a scenic spot where.

Rating: 10

Address: 62 Trinity Park, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557, United States

16. Nathan Mayhew Schoolhouse


Nathan Mayhew Schoolhouse is a significant museum in Chilmark, MA, USA. This charming schoolhouse holds excellent historical and cultural value for the local community and visitors alike.

Despite its small size, the museum offers a wealth of knowledge and insights into the educational system of the past.

Upon entering the Nathan Mayhew Schoolhouse, visitors are transported back to an era when education was vastly different from what it is today.


The description of the place does not provide much information, but the experience inside the museum is anything.

The schoolhouse’s interior has been carefully preserved to reflect the atmosphere of a traditional 19th-century classroom. You can observe the original as you step through the museum’s doors.

Address: Vineyard Haven, MA 02568, United States

Website: vineyardtrust.org

17. Edgartown Historic District


Edgartown Historic District is one of the most captivating historical places in Tisbury, MA, USA. Located on Martha’s Vineyard, this district is known for its rich history and well-preserved architecture.

The district is a testament to the town’s past and offers visitors a glimpse into the bygone era. One of the most prominent features of the Edgartown Historic District is its stunning collection of 18th and 19th-century homes.

These houses showcase the exquisite craftsmanship and architectural styles of the time, transporting visitors back to a different era.

The district’s cobblestone streets and picturesque gardens add charm and allure. Visitors can explore various landmarks and points of interest through the Edgartown Historic District. One.

Rating: 8.6

Phone: +1 508-627-6155

Address: 70 Main St, Edgartown, MA 02539, United States

Website: Edgartown-ma.us

18. Cape Poge Lighthouse


Cape Poge Lighthouse is one of the historical places in Tisbury, MA, USA. This iconic landmark holds a significant place in the history of the area.

The lighthouse is situated on Martha’s Vineyard, an island off Massachusetts’s coast. Cape Poge Lighthouse has a rich history dates back to its construction in 1801.

The lighthouse was initially built to guide ships navigating through the treacherous waters around Martha’s Vineyard.


It served as a vital beacon, warning sailors of the area’s dangerous shoals and rocky coastlines. The lighthouse, with its distinctive white exterior and black lantern room, stands tall against the picturesque backdrop of the island.

Its unique architectural design has become an.

Rating: 9.4

Address: 59 Lighthouse Rd, Edgartown, MA 02539, United States


Historical places in West Tisbury, MA, USA, hold significant cultural and historical value. They allow visitors to engage with the heritage and history of the town and represent a rich tapestry of architectural and cultural diversity.

These places help in understanding the town’s historical development, portraying the story of West Tisbury from its early settlers to the present day.

They provide educational opportunities for locals and tourists and contribute positively to the town’s identity and economy. Therefore, preserving these historical places is crucial for future generations to understand their past better.

Photo of author

Jaclyn Lowe

As a passionate historical house tour guide in Boston, Massachusetts, I am dedicated to bringing the rich history of this vibrant city to life. With a deep love for the past and a commitment to preserving its stories, I lead visitors on captivating journeys through centuries-old homes, sharing tales of Boston's illustrious past. With a wealth of knowledge and a flair for storytelling, I transport guests back in time, immersing them in the captivating narratives of the American Revolution, colonial life, and the evolution of this remarkable city. Join me on a journey through Boston's fascinating history and discover its hidden treasures. LinkedIn

Leave a Comment